Skip to main content

Free tool and guide

Commercial real estate underwriting, step by step

Underwriting turns a property's documents into a price, a loan size and a decision. Here are the steps in order, and a free checklist you can tick off and download.

Commercial real estate underwriting is the analysis a buyer or lender does before committing to a deal. It normalizes the T12, checks the rent roll against it, builds a pro forma, plans the capital, sizes the debt, runs the returns and sensitivities, and ends in an investment committee memo.

Underwriting checklist

Tick off each step as you underwrite a deal, see what is left, and download the checklist as a CSV. Nothing you tick is sent anywhere. It runs in your browser: your numbers are not uploaded, saved or tracked, and there is no sign-up.

0 of 37 items done

1. Collect the documents

Underwriting is only as good as what it reads. Ask for originals, not summaries.

2. Normalize the T12

Find the income and expenses the property actually produces, before anyone's projections.

3. Check the rent roll and tie it to the T12

Leases are promises; the T12 shows what was collected.

4. Build the pro forma

Your projection of income, expenses and NOI over the hold, built from the normalized numbers.

5. Plan the capital

What the property needs to keep its income, beyond operating expenses.

6. Size the debt

Lenders size loans to the lowest result of several tests. Their exact limits vary by lender, asset type and market, so get them from the lender.

7. Run the returns and sensitivities

What the deal earns, and how much it takes to break it.

8. Write it up

The decision rests on what the committee can check.

What underwriting is

Underwriting answers two questions about a property: what is it really earning, and what can it support? A buyer uses the answer to set a price and judge returns. A lender uses it to decide how much to lend and on what terms.

Underwriting sets the price or the loan; due diligence checks that the facts behind it are true, and what it finds feeds back into the underwriting. Both start from the same documents. The difference is the test at the end: a buyer looks at returns such as the cap rate, cash-on-cash return and equity multiple, while a lender looks at debt service coverage, debt yield and loan to value.

The steps, in order

  1. Collect the documents. The offering memorandum, rent roll, T12, main leases and third-party reports. Ask for spreadsheets, not PDFs, where you can.
  2. Normalize the T12. Check the totals, set aside one-time items, keep capital spending and debt service below NOI, and reset taxes where a sale triggers reassessment. The T12 guide and analyzer walks through it.
  3. Check the rent roll and tie it to the T12. Occupancy, loss to lease, rollover and tenant concentration, then compare annualized rent with recent collections. See the rent roll guide.
  4. Build the pro forma. Revenue, vacancy and credit loss, operating expenses and NOI for each year of the hold, with every difference from the broker's numbers explained. The OM checker helps compare them.
  5. Plan the capital. Reserves, tenant improvements and leasing commissions for rollover, and capital projects.
  6. Size the debt. Test the loan on DSCR, debt yield and loan to value, and take the strictest result. The commercial mortgage calculator shows payment, balloon and coverage together.
  7. Run the returns and sensitivities. Going-in cap rate, cash-on-cash, IRR and equity multiple, then move rent, vacancy, exit cap rate and interest rate to see what breaks the deal.
  8. Write it up. An investment committee memo with the thesis, the risks and the returns, every number traced to its source.

Equity and lender underwriting compared

QuestionEquity investorLender
Main goalPrice and returnLoan size and safety
Key measuresCap rate, cash-on-cash, IRR, equity multipleDSCR, debt yield, loan to value
Which NOIProjected NOI over the holdUsually in-place or near-term NOI, often with conservative adjustments
UpsideCounted, with sensitivitiesMostly left out

Where underwriting goes wrong

  • Taking the broker's pro forma as the starting point instead of the T12.
  • A rent roll that never gets tied to what the T12 shows was collected.
  • Lease expirations inside the hold with no downtime, free rent or leasing costs.
  • Property taxes left at the seller's level after a sale that triggers reassessment.
  • An exit cap rate lower than the going-in rate without a reason.
  • Numbers in the memo nobody can trace back to a document.

Using AI to underwrite

An AI assistant can take the first pass: reading the T12, rent roll and leases into your model and flagging what does not tie out, as long as every number links to the line it came from. The judgment calls stay with you. AI underwriting for CRE covers how that works, what AI actually works in CRE shows which underwriting jobs held up in testing, and is AI safe for deal documents covers which plans to use. If you are choosing a tool, see the underwriting software guide.

Frequently asked

What is underwriting in commercial real estate?
Underwriting is the analysis a buyer or lender does to decide whether a property is worth the price or the loan. It turns the property's documents into a view of its real income, its risks, how much debt it can carry and what it is likely to return.
What is the difference between equity and lender underwriting?
An equity investor underwrites to decide what to pay and what the deal returns. A lender underwrites to decide how much to lend and how safely the property covers the debt, mainly through debt service coverage, debt yield and loan to value. The documents are the same; the questions differ.
What DSCR do lenders require?
It varies by lender, loan program, property type and market, so this page gives no single number. Ask the lender for its minimums on debt service coverage, debt yield and loan to value, and size the loan to the strictest of them.
Can AI do commercial real estate underwriting?
It can do much of the first pass, such as reading a T12 or rent roll into a model, as long as every number links back to its source and a person checks the judgment calls. PSV's tests of which underwriting jobs AI does well are on the what AI actually works in CRE page.

Pacific Software Ventures built this tool and guide, and sells AI consulting and training to commercial real estate firms. This is general education, not investment, legal or tax advice.

Next step

Doing this on every deal? Let AI do the first read.

Ten minutes. An honest read on where AI would save your team time, and which option fits, including when it is not us.